When the former defender stepped into the role as the club's manager in January, he faced scant opportunity to get acclimated. An intense run of games signified a phased integration to his squad was impossible.
Local press warned of the obstacles he would confront, particularly handling a locker room full of some of football's most prominent stars.
Yet forging strong relationships with the players appeared not to worry the former Anfield defender.
"It's not something that worries me a lot," the coach stated at his inaugural news conference.
Two months since, he says those relationships are strengthening and the performances on the field are reflecting that.
Building Connections
In March, Arbeloa led his side to victories against sides led by world-class coaches: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Real Madrid are still a quartet of points behind La Liga pace-setters Barcelona, with a potentially decisive Clasico in May, while their Champions League campaign continues with a last-eight encounter against Bayern Munich.
The team's form are on the up and the dynamic between the manager and players are building.
"I am becoming to comprehend the individuals more and more," stated Arbeloa after his team's 3-2 success against rivals Atletico last week.
"I came in at a juncture when I almost had no time to observe the squad, to understand where they felt comfortable, and to observe how they interacted with one another."
He acknowledged the circumstances of his arrival posed new challenges.
"For me, it's challenging to come in the middle of the campaign and observe how the team works, and that is precisely what has evolved over these past eight weeks," he went on.
"At present I know my charges as individuals and footballers, where I can elicit the optimal performance from them, and where I can make adjustments."
Plaudits for Vinicius Jr
One player flourishing under the new manager is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of Arbeloa's 17 fixtures in charge, with his goal return also seeing a dramatic uptick - he has found the back of the net 11 times under Arbeloa, versus scoring just six in 27 outings under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has prioritized restoring the forward's morale, encouraging him to play freely and show his flair rather than limiting him systematically.
"I am fortunate to have Vinicius, he's adored by the supporters. We want to see the Vini who loves the game, who laughs, who dances… that is the player I want to see," Arbeloa said in his first news conference as manager.
That approach contrasts with reports of friction under Alonso, with the forward being heard to say "I will quit this club" after being substituted in last match against Barcelona.
The new boss has publicly stood up for him, stating clearly he is has the total confidence by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He's one of the most dangerous footballers, if not the most dangerous, in the world today and he embodies what a this club's player is," added Arbeloa.
The Brazilian placed talks about his long-term prospects on hold last off-season but, recently, he made his commitment clear.
"I am solely thinking about this club and staying here for a very long time," he informed the press before his national team's friendly with France.
Fede Valverde Regains Top Form Again
Fede Valverde's form has also improved dramatically since the new coach took charge.
During the tenure of Alonso, he managed three strikes and seven goal contributions from 31 games.
Since Arbeloa's appointment, he has been named in the starting eleven for each of the 17 of his matches in charge, finding the net seven times and providing five assists.
A primary cause has been a tactical repositioning back into the center of the park.
During Alonso's time in charge, the player at times had difficulty trying to secure a starting spot in his preferred position, being positioned in unfamiliar roles such as right-back.
While the choice was in part driven by injuries to other players, his frustration was obvious. "I was not born to be a right-back," he remarked.
But now, back in his preferred position, the midfielder is thriving.
He has netted six goals in just a month, including a three-goal haul against City and a decisive strike in a 3–2 victory over their city rivals.
More Players, More Potential?
Arbeloa's prior role as manager of the club's reserve team has made blending academy talents into the senior side feel seamless, so it was logical to expect him to give up-and-coming players chances.
That happened particularly when Real Madrid faced their opponents earlier this month and Arbeloa provided opportunities to six Castilla players.
One player, in particular, has rapidly established himself as one of Arbeloa's most exciting youngsters.
Being only 18 years and 226 days, he made history as the most youthful footballer in the team's records to start twice in the European Cup latter stages, breaking a previous record by 10 days.
Questioned what it signified to see several homegrown players on the pitch, he couldn't hide his joy.
"I believe I can die happy after a evening like tonight," he remarked.
"I was just talking to some of them, who were the first players I coached when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the chance to play at the Santiago Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While the coach might be familiar with the youth team players, he concedes injuries have restricted his exposure